Cherreads

Chapter 4 - Chapter 4: The Art of Pretending

I didn't answer right away.

The voice on the phone had vanished just as fast as it appeared, leaving only static—and questions.

I slid the burner into my pocket, careful not to let him see my hands shake.

He watched me like he could read my pulse. "What did they say?"

I smiled—sweet, fake, deadly. "Wrong number."

His eyes didn't move. "Emery…"

I tilted my head. "Is that really my name, or just what you need me to believe?"

A flicker. Just for a second. His mask slipped.

"I don't lie to you," he said, too softly.

I let the silence answer him.

He showed me to a penthouse that felt more like a museum—glass walls, marble floors, a grand piano no one played. Everything was beautiful, expensive, and cold.

"This is home," he said.

Home.

There were no photos. No warmth. No proof that I'd ever lived here.

I wandered to a mirror in the hallway. My face stared back at me—clear skin, full lips, dark eyes that held a storm.

I pressed my fingers to the glass. "Who are you?" I whispered.

Behind me, he appeared like a shadow.

"You used to love this place," he said. "Especially the view."

I turned. "Then show me proof."

He walked to a drawer, pulled out a velvet box, and placed it in my hand.

Inside: a ring.

Gold band. Blue sapphire. Elegant. Familiar.

My heart skipped.

I touched it, and—

FLASH.

Laughter. Wind. A rooftop.

My hand in his. The ring on my finger.

A whisper in my ear: "You're mine now, forever."

I gasped and dropped the box.

My knees hit the floor.

He reached for me, but I flinched.

"Don't."

His jaw tightened. "You're remembering."

I stood on my own.

Maybe I was.

Or maybe… I was just seeing what he wanted me to see.

Either way, I made a decision.

If he wanted to play games with memory—

I'd play better.

More Chapters