A Season of Learning and Reflection
As July unfolded, the academy entered a new phase of learning: Devotion to Mary and the Saints. This subject focused on Marian devotion, the importance of the Rosary, the lives of saints, and intercessory prayers.
Maria, along with her friends Catherine, Kate, Nathaniel, and Emily, immersed herself in these lessons. But unlike most of her classmates, Maria had a unique curiosity—she liked to compare religious beliefs and explore the differences and similarities between Christianity and Islam.
Being from Pakistan, she had grown up in a Muslim-majority culture, where Islam shaped everyday life. Now, as she studied Christian theology, she often found herself wondering:
"How does this compare to what I have seen and learned in Islamic culture?"
This curiosity led her to deeper discussions with her classmates and teachers.
---
The Rosary vs. Islamic Prayer Beads
One afternoon, Sister Alex entered the study hall, holding a Rosary in her hands.
Sister Alex: "Today, we will discuss the importance of the Rosary and why Marian devotion plays a central role in our spiritual lives."
Maria leaned forward, intrigued. She had seen something very similar in Islamic culture—the Misbaha (Islamic prayer beads).
Sister Alex: "The Rosary is not just a prayer; it is a spiritual weapon. It helps us meditate on the life of Christ and seek the intercession of Mary, the Mother of Jesus."
Maria raised her hand.
Maria: "Sister, I noticed that in Islam, people also use prayer beads called Misbaha to recite the names of God. Is this similar to the Rosary?"
Sister Alex smiled, appreciating Maria's analytical thinking.
Sister Alex: "That's an interesting comparison, Maria. Yes, both serve as tools for devotion and remembrance of God. However, while the Rosary is focused on the life of Jesus and Mary's intercession, the Misbaha is used to recite the 99 names of Allah or other forms of Dhikr (remembrance of God)."
Catherine, who was listening, nodded.
Catherine: "So, both help believers to stay connected to God, but in different ways?"
Sister Alex: "Exactly. Both traditions emphasize spiritual mindfulness and prayer."
Maria smiled. It was fascinating to see how different faiths used similar practices to strengthen their connection with God.
---
Mary in Christianity and Islam
As the weeks passed, another topic fascinated Maria: the role of Mary (Maryam) in both religions.
One day, Father Robert led a class on Marian devotion.
Father Robert: "Mary holds a unique position in Christianity. She was chosen by God to bear His Son, and she remained pure and faithful. Catholics and many other Christians venerate her as the Mother of God."
Maria, always eager to engage in meaningful discussions, raised her hand.
Maria: "Father, I read that Mary is also honored in Islam. She is even mentioned in the Quran more times than in the Bible. Could you explain how her role in Christianity is different?"
Father Robert's eyebrows lifted in pleasant surprise.
Father Robert: "That's a very good observation, Maria. Yes, Mary is deeply respected in Islam. In fact, she is the only woman mentioned by name in the Quran, and she is described as one of the most righteous women. However, the main difference is that Christianity believes Mary was the Mother of God, while Islam sees her as the mother of Prophet Isa (Jesus), but not divine herself."
Kate, who had been quiet, joined the discussion.
Kate: "Does Islam believe in the virgin birth of Jesus?"
Maria nodded.
Maria: "Yes, Islam teaches that Mary was a virgin when she gave birth to Jesus. It was a miraculous event, and she is considered a model of piety and obedience. But Muslims do not believe that Jesus was the Son of God. Instead, they see him as a prophet."
Father Robert smiled.
Father Robert: "That's a key theological difference. For Christians, Jesus is the Son of God and the Savior of the world, while in Islam, he is one of the greatest prophets of Allah, but not divine."
Nathaniel, deep in thought, added:
Nathaniel: "It's amazing how both faiths deeply respect Mary, even if they have different beliefs about Jesus."
Maria nodded.
Maria: "Yes, I think Mary serves as a bridge between Islam and Christianity. She represents purity, faith, and devotion in both religions."
The discussion left everyone inspired and reflective.
---
Intercessory Prayers vs. Direct Prayer
Another theological debate that interested Maria was the concept of intercessory prayers—the practice of asking saints to pray on one's behalf.
One evening, in the library, Maria turned to Sister Emily, one of the younger teachers.
Maria: "Sister Emily, I've been thinking about intercessory prayers. In Christianity, people pray to saints to intercede for them. But in Islam, people pray directly to God without any intermediaries. Why is there such a difference?"
Sister Emily smiled.
Sister Emily: "That's a great question, Maria. In Christianity, we believe that saints are already in God's presence and can pray for us, just as we ask friends or family to pray for us. We don't worship them; we seek their prayers, like asking a trusted friend for help."
Maria considered this.
Maria: "But in Islam, the belief is that people should ask directly from God. There is no concept of saints interceding."
Sister Emily: "Yes, that's a fundamental difference. Islam emphasizes direct monotheism (Tawhid), where all prayers go directly to Allah. Christianity, especially Catholicism, believes in the communion of saints—the idea that those in heaven can pray for those on earth."
Catherine, who had been listening, spoke up.
Catherine: "So, in both religions, the goal is still the same—to seek guidance and blessings from God?"
Maria smiled.
Maria: "Exactly. The path may be different, but the destination is the same—faith, devotion, and connection with God."
---
A Journey of Understanding
As September approached, Maria realized how much she had learned and grown in these three months.
She had discovered the similarities between Christian and Islamic prayer beads.
She had learned about Mary as a unifying figure between the two faiths.
She had explored the different approaches to prayer and intercession.
One evening, as Maria sat on her bed, she opened her journal and wrote:
"Faith is like a river—it may flow through different lands, take different paths, but in the end, it leads to the same ocean of divine love."
She smiled, feeling at peace. The more she learned, the more she understood the beauty of different faiths.
As she whispered her prayers that night, she thanked God for guiding her on this journey of understanding—one that had deepened not just her faith in Christianity but also her respect for Islam and all who seek the truth.